Creepy House

(this story is fake, but I have a recreation of the game, if you want to you can play it before you read so you can imagine the story better, here's the game)

(here's also the profiles of my friends in this story so you can imagine them too. nightmare cherry cranberry me, which isn't needed since it's first person locked but idc)

I was playing Roblox when I saw my IBF was online. I decided to ask if we could play together, and she said yes. She told me to join her, so I said ok. She joined a game called "creepy house", and I joined. It was a house. Pretty obvious from the title. What I noticed is that it was free models, and the only thing the creator made was the grass and rocks(?) surrounding it. We walked in, and it was dark. Good thing we had a flashlight. I noticed right away it was a free flashlight, since I've seen it before while making random games. It was the flashlight with an arm, that forced you in first person. The game was already first person locked anyways, so it made no difference. The original creator of the house was good at building, everything looked very realistic. There was a living room, bedroom, and a hallway. In the hallway there were two doors, but we weren't able to enter them.

Before we entered the basement, a user named "cranberry9909" joined. I said hi because she was my best friend, so it was normal. She answered back with another hi. We went to the front of the house, which is where she was. She then said, "wanna play a different game?", and both me and my friend answered with yes. We played games like Royale High, Skate Park, Slender Man's Revenge, and other games that we all liked. My other friend, which I'll call Cherry, asked if we wanted to play creepy house again. Me and Cranberry both said yes. Cherry also mentioned she invited Nightmare and he said yes.

We all joined a server, but it was only me, Cherry, and Nightmare. We found out it was a max 3 player game, so one of us couldn't play. Good thing we all had discord. We entered a call together and Cranberry shared her screen. Nightmare and Cranberry, who hadn't played the game, were exploring. Cherry was waiting at the front. They all were done, but Cherry said her mom had called her for a second, so she left for a second. I couldn't join since she hadn't left the game, so I just thought it was something short, like getting food, doing something for her, or other small things. We all waited for her. After about seven minutes Cherry came back with fast food. I said she was lucky, and that I was hungry.

They all entered the basement. They found out what was "creepy" about it. There was a noose, electric chair, and other things. I told them it was just freemodels from those "trap chamber" games. One of the things were broken but with a lot of blood all over the place, but we all just laughed at it. Wasn't even scary. In a bucket/bowl thingy, there was a head with a name titled Amy. I soon realized it was MY avatar.

My pink short hair. My dust mask. My devil horns. Even the pink-ish skin color. The thing is, I had that avatar yesterday but the game was made today. My friends told me it was just a coincidence since anyone could have that avatar. It didn't even have the body or the username, so I agreed. Nightmare just got kicked from the game when he touched the head. I think he tried to say help, but he got cut off before he finished. He left the call, and went offline. We thought it was a prank to scare us and to make Cherry and Cranberry leave the game, since he was the creator pretending to not be. Here's a bit of the conversation after that happened.

CH: "Is Nightmare okay? He just left the call in the middle of saying something like, "help", "hello", or "hell".

CR: "Probably a prank to make us scared of the game and leave."

ME: "I agree. He probably made it on another account and wants you two to leave because he didn't think you two would find it. Probably why my avatar might be the head."

CH: "True, probably. Yeah, I'm not scared.

CR: "Should one of us touch the head to make sure it was a prank?"

CH: "I will."

ME: "Be careful Cherry."

Cherry proceeded to touch the head. She got kicked. She started saying a word. Left the call. Went offline. We began to think it wasn't a prank, unless she wanted me to be worried since I said be careful. Cranberry told me she would open a window just in case something happened. She also picked up her phone since she was calling on it. She touched the head and got kicked from the game. I heard her scream, but she never left the call. I heard her hop out of her window and start running.

Good thing her room was on the first floor. We lived near eachother so she started to run to my house. She told me to tell my parents she was coming over. I started to hear her footsteps on the sidewalk. She was safe. I went to tell my parents she was coming over, then I heard the doorbell. I went to answer it, but nobody was there. On the ground, I saw my best friend. I saw Cranberry. Laying there.

I shook her a few times but she woke up. I can't explain how thankful I was that she was alive. I quickly took her inside of my house and asked what happened. She told me that when she got there, right as she rang the doorbell she got knocked out. When I asked who knocked her out, she told me it was a random girl. She explained what the girl looked like and I suddenly realized she was explaining what Cherry looked like. I told her, but she told me it couldn't be Cherry.

She slept over at my house and the next morning Cherry and Nightmare's deaths were on the news. I suddenly realized the girl who knocked Cranberry out, followed her, and tried to kill her wasn't Cherry. It was something, something that nobody probably knows about since it steals the last person it killed's identity. I called Cherry's parents and told them to kill "Cherry" the next time they saw her. They asked why would they kill their daughter. I feel bad for them the next time "Cherry" goes home.

The next morning I got a friend request from a user called, "CHERRYISALlVE33". I accepted and my screen went dark. I thought my computer was just dead, and I was correct. By the time it charged, the user chatted me. Here's how it went.

33: "Cherry is alive. Why do you think she's ####?"

ME: "tags"

33: "Ded."

ME: "o"

ME: "well her d--th was clearly on the news, u dumb or sumthing?"

33: "It was fake."

ME: "y wuld a fake d--th be on the news. yea ur dumb."

33: "Oh well then. You don't believe me."

33 quickly unfriended me after that. I joined creepy house again, which was renamed to "e". Probably to hide what happened to Cherry and Nightmare. I went to the basement, and looked in the bowl/bucket thing. There wasn't my head. It was Cherry's, and Nightmare's was on the ground next to it.

Another account requested me. The username was "cherchercherry3". I looked at the account a little bit, since the username was literally Cherry's but with a 3 at the end. Their avatar was Cherry's. They had every item Cherry had. I wondered about the outfits though. I went into that one outfit game with Cranberry and put Cherry's user in it while Cranberry put the fake one's in. They had the exact same outfits. I decided to accept, thinking it was an alt, forgetting Cherry was dead. She acted exactly like Cherry.

I decided to quit Roblox after that and let "Cherry" take whoever plays that game next.

(this story is fake, but I have a recreation of the game, if you want to you can play it and read the story again so you can imagine the story better, here's the game)

(here's also the profiles of my friends in this story so you can imagine them too. nightmare cherry cranberry me, which isn't needed since it's first person locked but idc)